Appeals To The Court Of Appeal
Found guilty at trial, or given a sentence that feels far too long? The Court of Appeal is the next step, and it is not automatic. Family of people in prison can call us.
- Family can call for someone already in prison
- We read the transcript and the judge's remarks
- Conviction, sentence or both? We advise on each
Someone inside wants to appeal?
What is the Court of Appeal?
The Court of Appeal is a specialised court for hearing appeals related to criminal sentences or convictions from the Magistrates’ (when presided over by a Chief Magistrate), County (in limited cases), and Supreme Courts in Victoria. Appeals in this court are extensive, involving detailed analysis of all evidence associated with the case.
Who has a Legal Right to Make an Appeal?
- Defendants can file an appeal against a sentence or conviction within 14 days of the court order in the Magistrates’, County, or Supreme Courts. Leave of the Court is required, except for sentences issued by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (CPA) (sections 274 and 278) outlines the necessary steps for appeal.
- The Prosecution (DPP) can appeal a sentence handed down to a defendant, known as a Crown or Director’s appeal. This right is controlled to prevent excessive appeals and does not require leave of the Court.
- Interlocutory Decisions: Either party may appeal against decisions by trial judges in the County or Supreme Courts.
A judge in the Court of Appeal will review whether leave is granted for a case to proceed (s 315 CPA), unlike appeals from the Magistrates’ Court to the County Court, which are automatically granted.
Documents Required for an Appeal
An extensive portfolio of documents is needed when applying for leave to appeal a sentence or conviction. For a sentence appeal, this may include sentencing remarks, and for a conviction appeal, court transcripts, exhibits, and police or prosecution materials. Both types of appeals require detailed documentation and precise instructions.
Time Limits for Appeals
Strict time limits apply to appeals in the Court of Appeal. The notice of appeal must be filed within:
- 28 business days of the sentencing date for sentence or conviction appeals (s 257 and 279 CPA).
- 2 or 10 days for interlocutory appeals, depending on the stage of criminal proceedings and trial judge approval (under ss 296(2) and 298(1) CPA).
The Registrar must notify the other party (usually the prosecution) within 7 days, allowing them 21 days to prepare a response. Applications filed outside these limits require an extension request supported by an affidavit explaining the delay, and the judge may accept or reject the application based on the adequacy of the reason (s 313 CPA).
Appealing a Conviction
Defendants appealing a conviction must file an application for leave to appeal, stating one of the following grounds:
- The jury’s decision was unreasonable or unsupported by evidence.
- A substantial irregularity or miscarriage of justice occurred (e.g., misdirection by the judge or unreliable witnesses).
- Exceptional circumstances, such as intimidation, fraud, or duress, led to a guilty plea.
The application must include supporting documentation, such as affidavits, character references, and relevant case law. In cases involving “fresh” and “compelling” evidence (s 326C CPA) or a substantial miscarriage of justice (s 326D CPA), the Court may grant leave for additional conviction appeals (s 326A CPA).
Appealing a Sentence
To appeal a sentence, defendants must file a notice of appeal and include a written submission with supporting arguments, legal references, and documentation like affidavits and sentencing remarks. The judge will assess if an error occurred, the surrounding circumstances of the case, and whether a different sentence should be imposed (s 281(3) and 282(1)(a) CPA). The Court may set aside, vary, or re-sentence, with a warning if a more severe sentence is possible, giving the defendant a chance to discontinue the appeal.
Factors considered include:
- The maximum penalty allowed and whether it was reasonably applied.
- The discretion exercised in the original sentence.
- Similar case outcomes.
- The severity of the offence and the defendant’s circumstances.
If leave is granted, an appeal hearing will follow, potentially resulting in a full retrial or acquittal. However, the Court may apply the proviso and dismiss the appeal, even if there was an irregularity in the trial.
Written Submissions
Written submissions are limited to 10 pages and should include:
- The sentence or conviction being appealed.
- The maximum legal penalty and other relevant legal references.
- Key facts, grounds for appeal, supporting arguments, references, and relevant transcript passages.
DPP Appeals Against a Sentence
If the DPP appeals at the same time as the defendant, the cases are heard together. The DPP does not generally require leave and may appeal if the sentence is “manifestly inadequate” or an error of law occurred. Like the defendant, the DPP must submit a written appeal with supporting arguments and documentation. The County Court can dismiss the appeal if it determines there is little likelihood of a less severe sentence being imposed.
When the DPP’s appeal is successful, the Court of Appeal must avoid “double jeopardy” when re-sentencing, ensuring fairness to the defendant.
Transcripts
Transcripts of the charge, plea, and sentencing remarks are provided by the Court Registry during the appeal hearing, though this process can take time due to resource constraints.
Abandoning an Appeal
The party initiating the appeal may abandon it by filing a notice with the Court before the hearing begins (s 314 CPA), leading to the appeal’s dismissal on the filing date.
Testimonials
What people Say
- MK law was fantastic to deal with in a challenging time, Lyndell and the team helped resolve my case with great professionalism and compared to th...MK law was fantastic to deal with in a challenging time, Lyndell and the team helped resolve my case with great professionalism and compared to the other law firms I asked for quotes from they were very fairly priced and it was never about the money, but always about getting the outcome I wanted.NG
- Dear Marcus, Lyndell and MK Law, Your professionalism, empathy and dedication have assisted me to get back to focusing on life with a clear pathwa...Dear Marcus, Lyndell and MK Law, Your professionalism, empathy and dedication have assisted me to get back to focusing on life with a clear pathway and very much appreciated. Thank you. Sincerely, AnthonyAnthony Tomsic
- I cannot thank Marcus, George and the team at MK Law enough for their help and guidance throughout my matter. From our very first conversation, Ma...I cannot thank Marcus, George and the team at MK Law enough for their help and guidance throughout my matter. From our very first conversation, Marcus made an incredibly stressful situation feel far more manageable. Paired with George, they were professional, communicative, and they genuinely invested in achieving the best outcome for me. I cannot recommend them highly enough!Sheridan Francis
- Marcus helped me out a lot when I desperately needed a legal representative. He was really easy going and genuinely thoughtful/helpful during very stressful times.Mark Saunders
Contact Us
If you’re considering an appeal from the Magistrates’, County, or Supreme Courts, MK Law is here to help. Appeals are complex and technical, and our experienced team can guide you through the process. We collaborate with Victoria’s top barristers to handle a wide range of appeals involving serious offences.
For an objective review, consider hiring different lawyers from those who represented you originally. Contact us early, ideally before transcripts are available. Reach us 24/7 for free legal advice at 1800 130 120 or marcus@mklawfirm.com.au. Many clients turn to us after unsuccessful attempts with other firms, and we’re here to support you.
Free Legal Advice 24/7
Contact Us
Call Anytime For Free Legal Advice 24/7
Top 5 firms by reputation dealing with traffic and criminal law matters.
- 2/212 Barkly Street, St Kilda Victoria, 3182 Australia
- 1800 130 120
- marcus@mklawfirm.com.au