Have you or your child been Charged with a “Category A” Serious Youth Offence?
- Over 30 years experience in the criminal justice system
- Track record of success
- Nationally acclaimed expertise
Free Legal Advice 24/7
What does it mean to be charged with a Category A Offence?
A Category A serious youth offence encompasses a range of serious criminal offences defined in the Criminal Procedure Act, 2009 (“CPA”).
These include, but are not limited to:
- Murder
- Attempted murder
- Manslaughter
- Child homicide
- Homicide by firearm
- Specific serious offences against the Crimes Act 1958 (“CA”), such as:
- Offences under various Commonwealth laws, including those related to terrorism.
What is the Definition of a Child:
Under the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005, (“CYFA”), a “child” is defined as a person who is:
- Under 18 years of age and at least 10 years old at the time of the alleged offence.
- Not including individuals who are 19 or older when proceedings commence.
General Rule for Hearing Charges:
Section 356 of the CYFA states that the Children’s Court typically must hear and determine indictable charges summarily (i.e., in a less formal and quicker process) for most Category A serious youth offences, except for six specific death-related offences (murder, attempted murder, manslaughter, child homicide, arson causing death, culpable driving causing death).
Conditions for Summary Hearing:
For a Category A serious youth offence to be heard summarily:
- Either the child or the prosecution must request it.
- The Court must be satisfied that the sentencing options available are sufficient for the offence.
- At least one of the following must apply:
- It is in the victim’s interest to have the matter heard summarily.
- The accused has cognitive impairment or mental illness.
- There are substantial and compelling reasons for summary hearing.
Uplift to Higher Courts
Mandatory Uplift:
Certain offences, particularly those involving death, must be heard in a higher court:
- Murder
- Attempted murder
- Manslaughter
- Child homicide
- Arson causing death
- Culpable driving causing death
Presumption of Uplift for Older Youth:
For individuals aged 16 years or older charged with specific Category A serious offences (e.g., aggravated home invasion, aggravated carjacking), there is a presumption that the case will be heard in a higher court.
Sentencing Considerations
Restrictions on Sentencing:
A court cannot impose a youth justice centre or youth residential centre order for a young offender convicted of a Category A serious youth offence unless exceptional circumstances exist. A young offender is defined as someone under 21 at the time of sentencing.
What is the difference between Category A and Category B Serious Youth Offences?
The distinction between Category A and Category B offences in Victoria primarily relates to the severity of the offences and the associated legal processes.
Examples include:
- Nature of Offences
- Category A Offences:
- These are considered the most serious youth offences and include crimes that typically involve severe harm or potential for fatal outcomes. Examples include:
- Murder
- Attempted murder
- Manslaughter
- Child homicide
- Arson causing death
- Culpable driving causing death
- Offences against the Crimes Act that involve significant violence or grave consequences also fall under this category.
- These are considered the most serious youth offences and include crimes that typically involve severe harm or potential for fatal outcomes. Examples include:
- Category B Offences:
- These are serious but less severe than Category A offences. They encompass serious crimes that can cause significant harm but generally do not result in death. Examples include:
- Recklessly causing serious injury in circumstances of gross violence
- Rape
- Home invasion
- Carjacking
- These are serious but less severe than Category A offences. They encompass serious crimes that can cause significant harm but generally do not result in death. Examples include:
- Legal Proceedings
- Category A Offences:
- Cases involving Category A offences must be heard in a higher court (such as the County Court or Supreme Court). There is a mandatory uplift for charges like murder, attempted murder, and manslaughter, meaning they cannot be heard summarily in the Children’s Court.
- Category B Offences:
- Generally, these charges can be heard in the Children’s Court through a summary process. However, if a child aged 16 or over is charged with a Category B offence, the court must consider whether there are exceptional circumstances that warrant transferring the case to a higher court
- Sentencing Implications
- Category A Offences:
- Sentencing for Category A offences is typically more severe, reflecting the serious nature of the crimes. The court may impose lengthy sentences, including potential imprisonment.
- Category B Offences:
- Sentencing options for young offenders charged with Category B offences are more restrictive if they have previous convictions for serious offences. A court cannot impose a youth justice centre or youth residential centre order for a young offender previously convicted of a Category A or B offence unless exceptional circumstances exist.
- Judicial Discretion
- Category A Offences:
- The judicial process is more rigid due to the severity of the crimes, leaving less room for discretion in how cases are handled.
- Category B Offences:
- There is some flexibility in how these cases are processed and sentenced, particularly concerning summary hearings and potential uplifts to higher courts.
Summary
In essence, being charged with a Category A serious youth offence in Victoria involves severe legal implications, including the potential for the case to be escalated to higher courts. The system emphasises both the seriousness of the offences and the need for a fair approach to youth offenders, balancing accountability with the opportunity for rehabilitation where possible. The legislative framework provides specific guidelines to ensure that serious offences are treated with the gravity they warrant while considering the developmental stage of the accused.
Testimonials
What people Say
-
I recently spoke with Daniel Moon from MK Law for legal guidance and was extremely impressed with his professionalism and clarity. He took the tim... Read More5/5
-
I had an outstanding experience with Daniel Moon from MK Law. He took the time to truly understand my situation and represented me with profession... Read More5/5
-
I want to sincerely thank my lawyer Mr Daniel Moon for representing me so well in court. He made me feel comfortable, as it was my first experienc... Read More5/5
-
Michael Sunderland from MK Law handled my matter with professionalism, respect, and genuine care. It was clear that he genuinely cared about gett... Read More5/5
Why choose MK Law?
Tailored Advocacy
When you choose MK Law, you can be confident that an expert will be fully dedicated to your case or your child’s case. We recognise that every situation is unique, and our lawyers take the time to listen, understand, and develop a tailored strategy that aligns with your specific needs. Our goal is to ensure that you receive the fairest and most just outcome possible, advocating fiercely on your behalf throughout the legal process.
Comprehensive Representation
Our team will represent you at every stage of the court proceedings, providing steadfast support and guidance. We understand how daunting it can be to face legal challenges, especially for young individuals. That’s why we strive to create a supportive environment where you can feel comfortable discussing your concerns and options. We will keep you informed every step of the way, ensuring you understand the legal proceedings and what to expect.
Expert Legal Advice
In addition to representation, MK Law offers expert advice on the best possible defences available to you. Our lawyers are well-versed in youth justice laws and are equipped to analyse your case from all angles. We will work diligently to identify the most effective strategies, whether that involves negotiating plea deals, presenting evidence, or challenging the prosecution’s case. Our aim is to safeguard your rights and ensure that your voice is heard in the courtroom.
Commitment to Justice
At MK Law, we believe in the power of justice and the importance of giving young people a second chance. Our passionate team is dedicated not just to winning cases but to making a positive impact on the lives of our clients. We are here to guide you through this challenging time and strive for outcomes that foster growth and rehabilitation.
Contact MK Law today on 1800 130 120 to learn how we can assist you or your child in navigating the complexities of the criminal justice system with confidence and expertise.
Contact Us
At MK Law Firm, we understand how overwhelming it can be when you or your child is charged with a “Category A” Serious Youth Offence. Our skilled and compassionate legal team is here to guide you through every step of the legal process, ensuring your rights are protected and your case is handled with care.
We provide expert advice, strong representation, and tailored legal solutions to help achieve the best possible outcome for your case.
For immediate assistance, contact MK Law Firm at 1800 130 120. We also offer 24/7 Free Legal Advice, so you can get the support you need—anytime, anywhere.
Free Legal Advice 24/7
Contact Us
Call Anytime For Free Legal Advice 24/7
Top 5 firms by reputation dealing with traffic and criminal law matters.
- 2/212 Barkly Street, St Kilda Victoria, 3182 Australia
- 1800 130 120
- marcus@mklawfirm.com.au